"45 Day (NO QUIBBLE) Money Back Guarantee"
Home PageUser CommentsCustomersTech SupportContact Us
 
 
Quick Tour
Virtual Instruments
Circuit Visualizations
Features
Schematics
Parts
Graphs and Timing Diagrams
Parameter Sweeping
Order And Evaluation
Simulation
Comparison
Database Editor
PCB Export
Electronics World
 

B² Spice A/D v4 Reviewed by Tom Harman

- back to previous

The following is an extract from an independent review published in audioXpress. - Tom Harman is a video systems engineer for Sony Electronics. He has been an audio hobbyist since age 14. He enjoys designing and building all audio equipment.

BRAND NEW PROFESSIONAL VERSION 4

B2 Spice v4 is a full-featured analog and digital SPICE electronic circuit simulation program distributed by RD Research.

This review is addressed to a "typical" audioXpress reader. I do not intend this to be for professionals. Should your international corporation buy a license for every engineer's desk? I do not answer that question here. This is a review written for audioXpress readers, by an audioXpress reader.

The primary difference between the £229 Professional Version and the £179 Standard Version is a larger library of parts (25,000 versus 5,000) and more simulations (25 versus 12). Either version is very attractive and competitive in the SPICE market. RD Research has the Professional Edition, fully functional, on a 30-day evaluation basis . The catch: Well actually there isn't one, it comes complete with the user manual and fully functional software. Thirty days should be long enough for you to decide whether you wish to keep the software or not.

WHY SPICE?

SPICE programs allow you to design and test (the SPICE term for test is "simulate") an electronic circuit, using a computer. No components to buy, no soldering irons to heat up, no smoking components. Why would you choose to use a SPICE program? For me, there are several answers:

1. Time - I can build a circuit quicker on my computer than I can on my test bench. I can change components quickly using a PC.

2. Education -I find technical material easier to follow if I build the circuit and "see" the ideas presented.

3. Maths - SPICE does the boring maths for me, so there is more time to experiment.

I do not want to mislead you. A SPICE program will not eliminate the prototype stage but it can shorten the design stage considerably. There are some real-world factors that might not be practical to simulate, such as: lead inductance, PCB capacitance, RF interference, real-world power supplies. Of course, SPICE does not have capacitors that are low distortion, nor can it tell you which cable sounds better

INTRODUCING THE SPICE GOALS

SPICE software has been around since the early 1970s. SPICE stands for "Simulation Program with Integrated Circuit Emphasis." Students and faculty at UC Berkeley first developed SPICE and have maintained it since. This is why some people call it "Berkeley SPICE." It has gone through three major revisions during the last 30 years.

Berkeley SPICE has become the world standard simulation engine. Almost all circuit simulation programs use the Berkeley SPICE engine as their core. This has the advantage of competition between products, but still continuity and familiarity among vendors. SPICE models need to be produced in a specific format; this makes them (more or less) interchangeable from one vendor's version of SPICE to another vendor's version. In fact, many component manufacturers supply free SPICE models of their products to encourage you to use their products in your designs.

SPICE was developed using public funding. The program is an open license. You can legally get versions free! Why should you spend $10,000 or even $99 for something you can get free?

Using the core SPICE program is cumbersome and anti-intuitive. There is no graphic input. You define your circuit using a text editor, such as Windows Notepad. Consider the following example. Figure 1 is a simple schematic and Table 1 is the SPICE file version of Fig. 1.

One line of text describes one component and how it is connected to the rest of the circuit. "R1 1 2 100.0W" tells you that R1 is a resistor, the first lead connected to node 1, the second lead is connected to node 2 and has a value of 100W ("Node" is a SPICE term for conductor). A file of a typical power amplifier would be large, difficult to edit or troubleshoot. Most (if not all) SPICE programs will come with a schematic drawing tool, called "schematic capture."

Select your components, place them on your sheet of paper, and then play connect-the-dots to wire your circuit. The software translates your graphic work into a file like the previous example to be used by the simulator. The core SPICE program comes with only a few basic components: resistors, capacitors, voltage sources, generic NPN transistor, and so on. Commercial SPICE programs come with a library of SPICE models for specific components, such as Analog Devices AD-711, TIP 32C transistor, IRF610 power FET, 12AX7 vacuum tubes. The SPICE program uses these models to predict how your circuit will behave.

When you specify a Texas Instruments TL071 op amp, you simulate the circuit using a TL071's electrical characteristics, such as bandwidth, gain, current draw, and so forth. The more accurate the model, the more accurate your simulation results will be. When evaluating a SPICE package, examine the library of components carefully.

- back to previous


Mail Us!